Ranking All of Neely Tubati Alexander’s Books

I’ve read all of Neely Tubati Alexander’s books and each one brings something unique to the table whether it’s slow-burn romance, self-discovery or forced proximity that reignites old feelings. If you’re wondering where to start or curious about my thoughts, here’s my ranking based on personal vibes, favorite tropes, and the emotional ride each story took me on:

Love Buzz (#3 in my ranking)

Pub Date: 5/2/23

Quick Summary: Serena meets a mysterious, charming stranger during a chaotic New Orleans bachelorette trip and becomes determined to find him once she’s back in Seattle. As she searches with only a few clues, she starts to question whether the carefully planned life she built is truly what she wants or if love might be worth the risk.

Thoughts: I had mixed feelings about it. The plot was intriguing and I didn’t mind that the romance took a backseat. I actually appreciated that the story focused more on Serena’s journey which was letting go of a job that no longer fulfilled her and ending a relationship she had clearly outgrown. It was empowering to watch her find a career she felt passionate about and even when she stumbled, she learned and moved forward. The part that didn’t work for me was the romance. I was fine with the insta-love setup between Serena and Julian, but her obsession with finding him after a brief encounter felt a bit unrealistic and hard to buy into. While the story centers on self-discovery and we do eventually learn how great Julian is, I wish they had reconnected earlier so we could actually see their relationship develop. The ending felt too rushed to fully enjoy the spark between them.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Courtroom Drama (#2 in my ranking)

Thank you to the author for the free ARC and to LibroFM & Harper Audio for the free ALC.

Pub Date: 5/20/25

Quick Summary: Sydney Parks thinks jury duty might finally bring some excitement to her life, especially when it involves a reality TV star on trial for murder. But things get messy fast when she realizes her long-lost childhood best friend is also on the jury, and old feelings start bubbling up at the worst possible time.

Thoughts: The plot felt original and intriguing. I loved how Neely balanced two subplots: Margot’s trial and the slow-building connection between Sydney and Damon. The character development was exceptionally well done. I don’t usually love single POV stories, but it worked perfectly here where each character felt deeply flawed yet relatable. The banter between Sydney and Damon was top-notch. The trial scenes were surprisingly engaging and kept me hooked all the way through. I also appreciated that the book included content warnings at the beginning of both the print and audio versions and the sensitive topics were handled with care. My only gripe was the pacing. I adored the slow burn and the pining between Sydney and Damon, but I wish we got to see more of their relationship after the trial wrapped up. Overall, I highly recommend picking this one up!

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

In a Not So Perfect World (#1 in my ranking)

Pub Date: 3/19/24

Quick Summary: Sloane Cooper, a video game designer focused on landing her dream job, agrees to pose as her neighbor Charlie’s fake girlfriend on a trip to Turks and Caicos. As sparks fly between them, Sloane struggles to stick to her career-first plan and avoid falling for someone who’s supposed to be winning back his ex.

Thoughts: I really enjoyed it! Some readers might not like how discriminatory the company Sloane interviews for is portrayed and while it may feel extreme, there is definitely some truth to it in the gaming world. I had a lot of empathy for Sloane and I could tell she was trying to prove something to herself. Charlie was a fun character although I thought he could have used more time to recover from his breakup before getting involved with Sloane. The banter between Charlie and Sloane was off the charts and the slow burn was perfect for their story. I loved all the activities they did during their vacation and how their connection gradually deepened. I appreciated that Sloane stayed focused on landing her dream job and that we got to see justice served at the end regarding the company. What did not work for me was the ending where everything felt tied up a little too neatly especially in terms of their work situations and how the third-act breakup was resolved.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Review: The Love Haters

The Love Haters by Katherine Center
Publisher: St. Martin’s Press
Pub Date: 5/20/2025

Thank you St. Martin’s Press for the free advanced copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Katie Vaughn takes a job profiling Coast Guard rescue swimmer Hutch Hutcheson, even though she can’t swim. As she spends time with Hutch and his family, she faces her fears, gets caught in a few lies, and starts to fall for him.

The Love Haters had such an intriguing plot. I ended up really enjoying it! The real standout in this book was the amount of research and thought Katherine Center put into the Coast Guard details. I enjoyed the slow burn, the banter, and the quirky side characters as well. Rue, George Bailey, and The Gals were a hoot! Beanie was an interesting best friend and cousin to Katie. Though I didn’t agree with all of her advice and some of it felt harsh, I appreciated that Katie had someone in her corner. The character dynamics in the book were interesting. I loved how Katherine built the connection between Katie and Hutch while also focusing on Katie’s journey of self-healing and self-love. For Hutch, the story centered on healing his relationships. Katie was an interesting main character and I can see how readers might either connect with her or find her frustrating. She tends to overthink and get stuck in her head, but considering her journey, her struggles made sense. Hutch occasionally felt a little too perfect or seemed to act hot and cold, but by the end, I understood why he was the way he was. I really wish we had gotten Hutch’s perspective because it would have been fascinating to see some of the resolutions from his point of view. The last half of the book took some unexpected twists which made things even more compelling. Overall, this was a solid four-star read.

Review: What Happens In Amsterdam

What Happens In Amsterdam by Rachel Lynn Solomon
Publisher: Berkley
Pub Date: 5/6/2025

Thank you Berkley Romance & PRH Audio for the free copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

After losing her job, Dani Dorfman impulsively moves to Amsterdam and unexpectedly reunites with her high school ex, Wouter. When they agree to a marriage of convenience, old feelings resurface forcing Dani to decide if this second chance is worth the risk.

What Happens In Amsterdam was one of my most anticipated reads! I enjoyed this one! I loved how Rachel brought Amsterdam to life as its own character which worked out beautifully. The storyline was engaging and the pacing was well done. I appreciated how Rachel explored Dani’s unemployment and burnout in a way that felt relatable and allowed us to really empathize with her. The connection between Dani and Wouter was sweet and I enjoyed how their relationship was built up with thoughtful flashbacks. I only wish we had gotten Wouter’s perspective at times. Other than that, I really loved this one.

Review: Shadows of You

Shadows of You by Catherine Cowles
Publisher: PageSmith LLC
Pub Date: 10/23/2023

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Aspen moves to a small town with Cady to escape a dangerous past and never expected to find protection and comfort in Roan, a gruff but kind-hearted man. As their bond deepens, the threats from her past resurface which forces Roan to risk everything to keep them safe.

Shadows of You is the fourth book in the Lost & Found series featuring Aspen and Roan. I’ve been curious about Aspen since we first met her in Echoes of You. Roan has been a background character from the beginning so I was excited to finally learn more about him. I ended up finishing this book in a day! Shadows of You deserves all the stars! I loved uncovering Aspen’s past which had twists I didn’t see coming. Also I loved getting to know Roan on a much deeper level. The blend of mystery and suspense kept me hooked. While I had an inkling about the culprit, there were still a few surprises that made this such a fun and engaging read. Shadows of You is definitely my favorite book in the Lost & Found series and is my favorite Catherine Cowles book so far!

Review: Wild and Wrangled

Wild and Wrangled by Lyla Sage
Publisher: Dial Press
Pub Date: 4/15/2025

Thank you PRH Audio for the free advanced copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

After being left at the altar, Camille Ashwood moves into her dream house only to discover her next-door neighbor is her first love, Dusty Tucker. As old feelings resurface, the two must confront their past and decide if love deserves a second chance.

Wild and Wrangled is the final book in the Rebel Blue series. This has been one of my most anticipated April reads! I found it to be a solid book to the series ending. I loved Cam’s character so much and my heart went out to her. I  appreciated the dual timeline with her past and present POVs which helped explain her history with Dusty and gave us a glimpse on how she met Gus. I really loved how Lyla was able to incorporate the other couples from the series and showed where they are now. While I enjoyed getting glimpses of Dusty’s perspective, I was yearning for more character growth from him. Overall, it was a sweet ending to the series. I’m looking forward to what Lyla writes next!

Review: The Sideways Life of Denny Voss

The Sideways Life of Denny Voss by Holly Kennedy
Publisher: Lake Union Publishing
Pub Date: 4/8/2025

Thank you Amazon Publishing & Brilliance Publishing for the free copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Denny Voss, living a quiet life in rural Minnesota, finds himself unexpectedly charged with murder after a series of well-meaning but chaotic misadventures. As he awaits trial, he unravels painful family secrets and learns what it means to take control of his future.

The Sideways Life of Denny Voss is the first book I’ve read by Holly Kennedy. This gave me strong Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine and The Maid vibes. I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly I devoured it. I ended up finishing it in a single day and absolutely loved it! Andrew Eiden did a fantastic job narrating. He truly brought the story to life! Holly Kennedy did an exceptional job capturing Denny’s perspective. I felt so much empathy for him.  I loved how certain characters showed their love for him in quiet but powerful ways. I also really enjoyed the multiple subplots and how well-developed each of the supporting characters were. I didn’t anticipate any of the twists and I had no idea how the story would turn out which made the reading experience even more engaging. There was one chapter near the end that made me cry which is something that rarely happens when I read so be prepared with tissues and maybe give your fur baby an extra cuddle. Overall, this was a 5-star read for me and I highly recommend it!

Review: Count My Lies

Count My Lies by Sophie Stava
Publisher: Gallery
Pub Date: 3/4/2025

Thank you Simon Audio and Libro.FM for the free audiobook copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️

Sloane Caraway, a habitual liar, lands a nanny job with a wealthy New York family after a small deception. But as she gets closer to them, she realizes she’s not the only one keeping dangerous secrets.

Count My Lies is GMA’s March pick. Unfortunately, this was a miss for me. The premise sounded promising, but the execution fell flat. The writing felt more like telling than showing which lacked depth though it was slightly entertaining. This book was essentially a bland mix of The Last Mrs. Parrish and The Housemaid, but without the intrigue that made those stand out. The characters were one-dimensional and the Taylor Swift references felt overused. I found the twists along with the ending to be predictable and underwhelming. The ending was especially unrealistic. Overall, it left me surprised that this was chosen as a book club pick. I would not recommend picking this up. 

Review: Wild Side

Wild Side by Elsie Silver
Publisher: Bloom Books
Pub Date: 3/4/2025

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

In Wild Side by Elsie Silver, Tabitha marries Rhys, the man she swore to hate, to keep custody of her nephew, Milo. But as they live together, Tabitha sees a different side in Rhys which she can’t resist.

Wild Side is the third book in the Rose Hill series which features Rhys and Tabitha. It can be read as a standalone, but I highly recommend reading the previous books first for the best experience. I’ve noticed a pattern in Elsie Silver’s books where the third book in a series becomes my favorite like Powerless in the Chestnut Springs series and The Front Runner in the Gold Rush Ranch series. Wild Side deserves all the stars! This is my favorite in the Rose Hill series so far. I loved how Elsie built up Tabitha and Rhys’s backstories, allowing us to see their individual healing journeys as well as their growth together. She also seamlessly integrated Milo, Tabitha’s parents, and other Rose Hill characters while keeping the story moving. The slow burn in this book was chef’s kiss! The epilogue was beautifully written. Now I can’t wait for the final book in the Rose Hill series, Wild Card!

Review: Story of My Life

Story of My Life by Lucy Score
Publisher: Bloom
Pub Date: 3/11/2025

Thank you Bloom Books for the free advanced copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

When Hazel impulsively buys a house in rural Pennsylvania to break through writer’s block, she discovers inspiration in the town’s rugged charm and her grumpy yet attractive contractor, Cam. But immersing herself in small-town drama might complicate more than just her next novel.

Story of My Life is the first book in the Story Lake series. I had mixed feelings about it. I liked the plot which felt like a mix between Things We Never Got Over and Maggie Moves On. Hazel was sweet and I loved learning about her writing process. However, I wasn’t a fan of Campbell’s character. He was immature, ran hot and cold, threw temper tantrums, and needed to communicate like an adult. The romance between Hazel and Cam felt abrupt and awkward which shifted strangely from grumpy interactions to friends with benefits. On a positive note, the quirky supporting characters and charming small-town setting were highlights. Overall, the story’s pace was too slow and uneven for me. I missed the usual element of mystery that Lucy Score typically includes. Even though this book wasn’t my favorite, I’m still looking forward to reading Zoey and Gage’s story next.

Review: Back After This

Back After This by Linda Holmes
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Pub Date: 2/25/2025

Thank you Random House for the free advanced copy. 

Rating: ⭐️⭐️

Podcast producer Cecily Foster is reluctantly thrust into the spotlight, hosting a series about her own dating life under the guidance of a controlling influencer. Torn between sparks with a charming photographer and the pressure to follow her mentor’s rules, Cecily must decide whether to trust her instincts or risk losing her shot at real love.

Back After This is the third book I’ve read by Linda Holmes, and the premise initially sounded intriguing. At first, I enjoyed getting to know Cecily’s character especially her personality at work, but the book’s pacing quickly became slow and drawn out. I wasn’t a fan of Eliza’s character and kept hoping she would improve, but she never did. Most of the characters felt underdeveloped, especially Will, whose backstory and personality were barely explored. The conversations between Will and Cecily felt stilted and their connection seemed based more on repeated encounters than genuine chemistry or spark. Cecily, as a protagonist, came across as a workaholic who relied too much drinking and lacked hobbies or interests outside her job. Her friendship with Julie felt one-sided where Cecily seemed to sacrifice unnecessarily for Julie who didn’t ask for such devotion and placed her friend on an undeserved pedestal. By the time I reached the 60% mark, I found myself bored and tempted to DNF, but since I’d made it so far, I pushed through. Unfortunately, the ending was underwhelming and it felt like the author added unnecessary descriptions and filler dialogue to meet a word count. Overall, this book confirmed that Linda Holmes’ style may not be for me.